Superstorm Sandy Long Beach Island sand dunes controversy - Fox 2 News Headlines

Superstorm Sandy

Long Beach Island sand dunes protected some homes

Posted: Updated:
MYFOXNY.COM -

When Superstorm Sandy struck Long Beach Island, N.J., some homes along the waterfront were surprisingly unscathed by flooding. Experts say that is because of dunes that were built 22 feet high.

In the Brant Beach section of Long Beach Island, beachfront homeowners gave the Army Corps of Engineers the OK to build beach protection. Stewart Farrell, a geologist and director of the Coastal Research Center at Stockton College said the dune project worked.

"They were wide enough and high enough to absorb the energy from Hurricane Sandy, at this location they did a fine job of protecting homes as opposed to elsewhere," he said.

But just A few miles down the island in the Holgate section, things look very different.

Vinny Renz's summer home was lifted up and twisted 90 degrees by the storm's surge. The house is located one block from the beach, where there were no reinforced dunes because many of Renz's beachfront neighbors had yet to consent to the dune project.

Despite their apparent effectiveness, not everyone wants the dunes in their backyard.

Some of the beachfront home owners are concerned that by allowing the government to build sand dunes with taxpayer money, the beaches would become public. And then there are concerns about the oceanfront views.

"When that dune is at 22 feet high, you can't see the beach," said Peter Wegener, an attorney representing Harvey and Phyllis Karan, homeowners in the borough of Harvey Cedars on Long Beach Island, where dunes were rebuilt in 2010.

He said the dunes have hurt property values, which is why his clients refused to turn over their portion of the beach for the project to begin with.

Instead, Harvey Cedars used eminent domain to seize the land.

"We're not opposed to dunes, never have been," Wegener said. "The point is if everyone else in town benefits from the dunes, they're asking property owners on the beach to be the only ones to pay for it."

As part of the eminent domain action, a jury awarded Wegener's client $375,000 to compensate for lost property value, a judgment that has been upheld by an appeals court and will now be challenged again in state Supreme Court.

It is a legal battle that Long Beach Township Mayor Joe Mancini would like to avoid. So he now plans to enforce a law already on the books that says if a homeowner refuses to allow the Army Corps to do beach reconstruction on their property, they'll have to pay for it themselves.

What do he say to homeowners who say the dunes affect their views and property value?

"Go upstairs, raise the roof," Mancini said. "It's more important to have safety for yourself and your neighbors than views from every floor."

Back in Holgate, Vinny Renz hopes Sandy's impact will make some of his neighbors who have held out reconsider the dunes project.

"We're in the process of deciding what we do here, and some of that depends on what happens with the dunes," he said.

  • New Jersey NewsNew Jersey NewsMore>>

  • Court rules for township: Mathis will not be reinstated as chief

    Court rules for township: Mathis will not be reinstated as chief

    Friday, August 1 2014 11:52 AM EDT2014-08-01 15:52:06 GMT
    Superior Court Judge Mark Cirocca ruled Thursday in favor of the Township of Berkeley Heights and Mayor Joe Bruno in their case against former Police Chief Mike Mathis, who will not be reinstated to his position. In his decision, Cirocco stated that Mathis failed to demonstrate "by clear and convincing evidence" that Bruno lacked the authority to unilaterally accept Mathis' resignation as set forth in the protocols of the Berkeley Heights Township Municipal Code.
    Superior Court Judge Mark Cirocca ruled Thursday in favor of the Township of Berkeley Heights and Mayor Joe Bruno in their case against former Police Chief Mike Mathis, who will not be reinstated to his position. In his decision, Cirocco stated that Mathis failed to demonstrate "by clear and convincing evidence" that Bruno lacked the authority to unilaterally accept Mathis' resignation as set forth in the protocols of the Berkeley Heights Township Municipal Code.
  • Montclair State University to make SAT & ACT scores optional

    Montclair State University to make SAT & ACT scores optional

    Friday, August 1 2014 11:20 AM EDT2014-08-01 15:20:34 GMT
    Photo courtesy of TAPinto.netPhoto courtesy of TAPinto.net
    Montclair State University (MSU) announced Tuesday that it will join the ranks of more than 800 of the nation’s leading colleges and universities and make the SAT/ACT test an optional requirement for all applicants seeking undergraduate admission. This announcement makes MSU the first public university in New Jersey do so.
    Montclair State University (MSU) announced Tuesday that it will join the ranks of more than 800 of the nation’s leading colleges and universities and make the SAT/ACT test an optional requirement for all applicants seeking undergraduate admission. This announcement makes MSU the first public university in New Jersey do so.
  • Shooting at NJ Transit station

    Shooting at NJ Transit station

    Friday, August 1 2014 8:53 AM EDT2014-08-01 12:53:14 GMT
    Police were investigating a shooting at the NJ Transit train station in Elizabeth, N.J. on Friday morning.  It apparently happened around 4:30 a.m. The victim was shot in the leg in an apparent robbery.
    Police were investigating a shooting at the NJ Transit train station in Elizabeth, N.J. on Friday morning.  It apparently happened around 4:30 a.m. The victim was shot in the leg in an apparent robbery.
Powered by WorldNow

WJBK-TV | Fox 2
16550 West Nine Mile Rd.
Southfield, MI 48075

Main Station: (248) 557-2000
Newsroom: (248) 552-5103

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices